try another color:
try another fontsize: 60% 70% 80% 90%
tom boone dot com
Excavating the grey area between pop culture and reality...

‘Rock Star: INXS’ Week 10

Rock Star: INXSDon't worry, folks. This will all be over soon... With this week's performances on "Rock Star: INXS," the competition to become the new lead singer of INXS officially became a two-horse race. The first competitor to take the stage last night was my long-time favorite, Suzie McNeil. Week after week, she's never failed to wow me. Until now. Instead of sticking with the effortless performance style that brought her this far, she tried to kick things up a notch. Unfortunately, she added a bit too much energy, and her performances of Stone Temple Pilot's "Interstate Love Song" and 4 Non Blondes’ "What's Up" were manic and off-key. The self-styled "Queen of the Bottom Three" is headed for yet another Wednesday night performance and may finally be headed home. In the last couple of weeks, J.D. Fortune has staged quite a little comeback. Following a mid-competition slump, he is once again turning in consistently strong performances, and appears to be peaking at just the right time. Last night's performances of his own original song "Pretty Vegas" and Pink Floyd's "Money" were two of his best. The fact that he aced "Money," a song with a tricky 7/4 time signature, should serve him particularly well with the band. All in all, J.D. is making a strong case for victory. So is Marty Casey, and his renditions of the original "Trees" and Radiohead's "Creep" were strong statements in their own right. With the exception of a couple of notes on "Creep," Marty actually stuck with the more melodic part of his voice for once, and he sounded better than usual as a result. The only downside: his acoustic treatment of "Trees" paled in comparison to last week's full band arrangement. The night limped to the finish with another in a long line of sappy performances by MiG Ayesa. While preparing to sing The Rolling Stones’ "Paint It Black," MiG claimed he was going to show his dark side -- and then performed an arrangement of the song that sounded like something out of a neon piano bar on Fremont Street. He followed that up with a version of "Kiss from a Rose" that would even put Seal to sleep. If voters would only cooperate, I suspect that the members of INXS would love nothing more than to send this guy packing. Predictions... No matter where they end up in the voting, bona fide co-frontrunners J.D. and Marty aren't going anywhere this week. History suggests that Australian and Asian voting will lift MiG out of the bottom three once again, which will leave INXS with no choice but to send Suzie home. I, however, think that MiG will finally get the punishment from voters he deserves. If he does, expect him to butcher an INXS song and get the ax. Besides, I suspect that the band (and CBS) would prefer to have a female contestant in the mix for next week's finale. Encore: J.D. Bottom Three: Suzie J.D. MiG Eliminated: MiG The "Rock Star" Graveyard... Dana Wil Neal Heather Daphna Tara Brandon Jessica Deanna Ty Jordis

4 comments so far...

1
PusBoy said...
You were essentially right in your predictions, with the exception of Mig butchering his song. I thought he carried it off well. That being said, I believe, now more than ever that there's a good chance that the fix is in. If Mig wins this thing, I am never going to watch CBS again. Except for the NFL. The fact that Mig went 12 weeks without ever being in the bottom three provided INXS with the perfect cover to oust Suzie instead of Mig. You and my wife have nudged me slowly into the Suzie camp, and there's no way she should have gone home last night. Honestly, I was surprised that JD wasn't sacrificed before Suzie, if indeed the fix is in. Maybe the plan is to give Marty and JD incredibly hard songs to sing (arias from Tosca, perhaps) and then let Mig sing Happy Birthday. I hate to believe that the fix is in, since I've invested far too much of my life actually watching and caring about this show, but there definitely something wrong in the way this was carried out. I suppose there's nothing technically wrong if the people in Australia voted their hearts, but it kinda tarnishes what's supposed to be a "talent competition." Right? Anyway.
2
no true bill said...
The only way MiG wins this thing is if it's fixed. Otherwise, I think INXS just brought him along to the finale to make their fellow countrymen happy. If the show is fixed, then everybody involved did a pretty poor job of selling MiG to INXS's non-Australian fans. And I did think MiG butchered his song last night. At the very least, his was easily the worst performance of the night.
3
Michael Swanson said...
I really don't think that any of them are suitable for the band. But if I had to pick one I would pick J.D. His song Pretty Vegas totally rocks, and aside from that he's the only one that consistently showed he was in a competition. I don't much care for Marty, his screaming-singing style isn't appropriate for INXS music. And aside from that it's just irritating to listen to. If a woman were to front INXS then I would have liked to seen Jessica do it, I like her tough chick demeanor and for the most part she sings INXS songs pretty good. Talented or not, Suzie's a big wuss and cries too much, not very rock n' roll-ish. She would be good in a candy-ass pop band. I started having suspicions about Mig four or five weeks ago. I think he's definately a ringer. The foregone conclusion is that it'll be interesting to see how he fronts the band. It's too bad they didn't have at least one more Australian in the "contest" for comparison sake.
4
PusBoy said...
In watching the clips of Mig's last performance on the "Mansion Show" last night, I tend to agree with you, NTB, that his performance was the weakest of the night. Last night's show certainly made it appear that Marty was the lead dog, and that JD and Mig have too many flaws. That being said, I have seen too many Mark Burnett shows to know that this type of editing usually leads viewers down the wrong path. So, I fully expect J.D. to win, since he seemed like the least likely to win after last night's show.

Add your comments...

  • You may post code using <code>...</code> (generic) or <?php ... ?> (highlighted PHP) tags.

More information about formatting options

Syndicate content